Anua Rice Toner vs Heartleaf Toner: Which One Should You Buy?

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through my links, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

If your real question is whether you need a milky toner at all, read my best Korean milky toners on Amazon guide after this.

If you are comparing Anua Rice Toner vs Heartleaf Toner, you are probably not asking which bottle is prettier. You are asking which one belongs in your routine, which one feels better under sunscreen, and which one is less likely to sit on your shelf after the first week. That is the right way to compare them, because these two toners are not the same type of product.

The short answer: choose Anua Rice 70 Glow Milky Toner if your skin is dry, dull, tight after cleansing, or you want a soft glass-skin base before makeup. Choose Anua Heartleaf 77 Soothing Toner if your skin is oily, easily red-looking, acne-prone, or you want a light watery toner that disappears fast.

Actual Products Mentioned

Use these product photos to match the packaging before you click through or compare listings.

Anua Heartleaf 77 Toner

Check on Amazon

Anua Rice 70 Glow Milky Toner

Check on Amazon

I would not think of this as one toner being better than the other. Rice is the milky glow toner. Heartleaf is the light calm toner. That difference sounds simple, but it changes everything: texture, finish, skin type match, makeup prep, and how easy the toner is to use every day.

I already wrote full reviews for both sides: my Anua Rice Toner review and my Anua Heartleaf 77 Toner review. This comparison is the buying-decision version. If you only want the answer before adding one to cart, start here.

Quick Verdict

Buy Rice if your skin needs comfort. The Rice 70 toner gives a soft milky layer that makes dry skin feel less tight and makes base makeup look smoother. It is the one I would pick for winter, dry cheeks, makeup prep, and that cushioned K-beauty glow.

Buy Heartleaf if your skin needs lightness. The Heartleaf 77 toner is watery, simple to layer, and easier for oily or breakout-prone routines. It is the one I would pick for summer, shine, post-cleanse freshness, and skin that dislikes creamy textures.

If you have to choose only one, choose by texture first. That is more useful than choosing by ingredient trend. If you hate milky toners, Rice will annoy you even if the ingredient list sounds good. If watery toners feel too basic for your dry skin, Heartleaf may feel underwhelming.

Main Difference: Milky Glow vs Light Calm

Anua Rice 70 Glow Milky Toner is built around a milky texture and a glow-focused finish. The product story centers on rice water, niacinamide, ceramides, and panthenol. In daily routine language, that means it is trying to make skin feel softer, look smoother, and sit better under the rest of your skincare.

Anua Heartleaf 77 Soothing Toner is built around a watery calming toner feel. The heartleaf story is all about light, fresh, calming hydration. In routine language, that means it is easier to use when your skin feels hot, oily, or easily bothered by heavier layers.

That is why the comparison should not start with which ingredient sounds more exciting. It should start with the finish you want on your face after cleansing. Rice leaves more of a soft skin-conditioning feel. Heartleaf feels cleaner and quicker.

Comparison Table

Choose Anua Rice Toner If...

Choose Anua Rice 70 Glow Milky Toner if your skin feels tight after cleansing. That tight feeling is a sign your routine needs a comfort layer before serum and moisturizer. A watery toner can help, but a milky toner usually feels more satisfying on dry cheeks.

Choose Rice if your skin looks flat even when it is not flaky. This is a very common dry-skin problem. Your routine is technically fine, but your face still looks tired. A milky toner can make the skin surface look softer, which helps the rest of the routine read as glow instead of grease.

Choose Rice if makeup grabs around your mouth, cheeks, or nose. I would use one thin layer after cleansing, wait, then continue with serum, moisturizer, sunscreen, and makeup. The point is not to make the face slippery. The point is to soften the base so foundation has less dry texture to catch on.

Choose Rice if you are building a Korean skincare routine for dry skin. It fits the toner slot better than Heartleaf when the routine needs comfort. It is not a replacement for moisturizer, but it can make moisturizer feel like it is working on a better base.

Choose Anua Heartleaf Toner If...

Choose Anua Heartleaf 77 Soothing Toner if your skin gets oily fast or if you hate feeling a layer on your face. This toner makes more sense when you want hydration but do not want a milky finish. It is the easier pick for a routine that already has a serum and moisturizer doing the heavier work.

Choose Heartleaf if your skin is acne-prone and you are nervous about creamy textures. No toner can promise breakout-free results for everyone, but a watery toner is usually less stressful to test than a milky one. If you are using acne treatments that already make your routine complicated, Heartleaf keeps the toner step simple.

Choose Heartleaf if you live somewhere humid or you use a rich sunscreen. A milky toner plus rich sunscreen can be too much on some mornings. Heartleaf gives you a cleaner first step and lets sunscreen be the main finishing layer.

Choose Heartleaf if your goal is calm, not glow. That distinction matters. A lot of people buy glow products when their skin is asking for fewer layers. If your face feels warm, shiny, or easily reactive, the lighter toner is the more practical move.

For Dry Skin

For dry skin, Rice wins most of the time. It gives more comfort after cleansing and works better as a soft base under serum. If your skin gets flaky, tight, or dull, Anua Rice 70 toner is the more natural choice.

Heartleaf can still work for dry skin if you prefer watery layers, but you may need to apply more than one layer or pair it with a stronger serum. That is not wrong. It just means Heartleaf needs more support in a dry-skin routine.

If your skin is dry but clog-prone, start with one layer of Rice, not three. Milky toner is not meant to be poured on like a mask. Use enough to soften the skin, then stop. That is the difference between dewy and sticky.

For Oily Skin

For oily skin, Heartleaf is usually the safer first pick. It is lighter, faster, and easier to layer without adding a dewy film. If your skin gets shiny by noon, Anua Heartleaf 77 toner is less likely to fight with sunscreen or makeup.

Rice can still work for oily skin in small amounts, especially in winter or when cheeks are dry. I would use it only where needed. One of the best routine habits is treating different face zones differently. Your cheeks and T-zone do not always need the same toner amount.

If your oily skin also feels dehydrated, Heartleaf first makes sense. If it still feels too light after a week, then Rice may be worth testing as a cheek-only layer.

For Acne-Prone Skin

For acne-prone skin, I would usually start with Heartleaf. A watery toner is easier to test because it adds less richness to the routine. If you are already using actives, benzoyl peroxide, retinoids, or exfoliating acids, simple support steps are your friend.

That said, acne-prone skin can still be dry. If your acne routine has made your skin tight or flaky, Rice may be helpful. The key is to introduce it carefully. Use it at night first, keep the rest of the routine steady, and do not add several new products in the same week.

If you need a full acne-focused setup, read my Korean skincare routine for acne-prone skin. A toner can support that routine, but it should not be the whole plan.

For Makeup Prep

For makeup prep, Rice wins when the problem is dry patches. It makes the skin feel more cushioned and can help foundation sit better. Use a small amount and wait before sunscreen. If you rush, the base can feel too slippery.

Heartleaf wins when the problem is too much shine. If your makeup breaks apart because your skincare is too rich, Heartleaf gives a cleaner starting point. It hydrates without pushing the finish too glossy.

My rule: if foundation clings, choose Rice. If foundation slides, choose Heartleaf. That is more useful than copying another routine step by step.

Can You Use Both?

Yes, but I would not buy both at the same time unless you already know your skin likes toners. If you own both, use Heartleaf when your skin feels oily, hot, or like it wants a lighter routine. Use Rice when your skin feels dry, tight, or dull.

You can also use Heartleaf in the morning and Rice at night. That split makes sense for combination skin. Morning routines often need less slip. Night routines can handle more comfort.

I would not layer both every day just because they are from the same brand. Layering can be useful, but it can also blur the job of each product. Try one at a time first so you know what each toner is doing.

Which One Is Better For Glass Skin?

Rice is better for a glass-skin look because it gives a milky glow layer. If your goal is that soft, reflective, hydrated finish, Anua Rice 70 Glow Milky Toner is the stronger pick.

Heartleaf can still be part of a glass-skin routine, but it plays a lighter support role. It helps the routine feel fresh, then your serum, moisturizer, and sunscreen create more of the visible finish.

If your skin is oily, be careful with chasing glass skin. On oily skin, glass skin can turn into shine fast. Heartleaf may be the better route because it gives hydration without pushing the finish too far.

Which One Should You Buy On Amazon?

If you are buying on Amazon, I would choose based on your current routine gap. Buy Anua Rice 70 Glow Milky Toner if your toner step feels too light or if your dry skin needs a soft base. Buy Anua Heartleaf 77 Soothing Toner if your routine already has enough richness and you want a fresh watery step.

Check the seller, current price, shipping, and return details before ordering. Beauty listings can change. The product you choose should match your skin, but the listing should also look clean and current.

If you are comparing more than these two, start with my best Korean toner guide or my new viral Korean skincare on Amazon hub. Those pages give you other routes if neither Anua toner sounds right.

Final Verdict

In the Anua Rice Toner vs Heartleaf Toner comparison, Rice is the better pick for dry skin, dull skin, makeup prep, and a milky glass-skin finish. Heartleaf is the better pick for oily skin, acne-prone routines, humid weather, and a light calming toner step.

If I were buying one for a dry-skin routine, I would pick Rice. If I were buying one for an oily or breakout-prone routine, I would pick Heartleaf. If I had combination skin, I would choose based on the season: Heartleaf for humid months, Rice for dry months.

The best toner is the one you will use without overthinking. Rice makes the routine feel softer. Heartleaf makes the routine feel lighter. That is the whole decision.

FAQ

Is Anua Rice Toner better than Heartleaf Toner?

Anua Rice Toner is better for dry skin, dull skin, makeup prep, and a milky glow. Heartleaf Toner is better for oily skin, acne-prone routines, and lighter hydration.

Which Anua toner is better for acne-prone skin?

Heartleaf is usually the safer first pick for acne-prone skin because it is lighter and watery. Rice can work if acne-prone skin is also dry, but start with one thin layer.

Which Anua toner is better for dry skin?

Rice is usually better for dry skin because the milky texture gives more comfort after cleansing and helps the routine feel softer before serum and moisturizer.

Can I use Anua Rice Toner and Heartleaf Toner together?

Yes, but it is better to test them separately first. You can use Heartleaf in the morning and Rice at night if your skin likes both textures.

Which Anua toner should I buy first?

Buy Rice first if your skin feels dry or dull. Buy Heartleaf first if your skin is oily, easily red-looking, or you want the lightest toner option.